Setback for Publishers: Photocopying of Books Okay in Delhi University

Towards the end of last year, driving distributed houses including Oxford University Press and Cambridge University Press brought a copyright activity against Delhi University and a modest photocopy shop authorized by it, trying to control them from supplying instructive course packs to understudies. This claim sent chill waves over the scholarly group, driving more than 300 creators and scholastic including celebrated around the world Nobel laureate Professor Amartya Sen to dissent this copyright animosity in a public statement to distributors. Obviously, 33 of the writers of different books said particularly in the claim marked this challenge letter making it clear that they were separating themselves from this lamentable claim.

For those not acquainted with the term, course packs are assemblages of constrained passages from copyrighted books, set up together meticulously by employees as per a painstakingly planned syllabus and educating arrangement.

What makes the claim especially deplorable is the way that distributors are successfully looking for an altogether prohibition on all course packs, even those that concentrate and utilize close to 10% of the copyrighted book. Under U.S. law, replicating up to 10% of the copyrighted books is “reasonable use” of a copyrighted work, and thus legitimate. Given that India is a developing nation, with poorer understudies and more serious instructive access requirements, it makes sense that Indian courts should raise this number at 30% or considerably higher.

Despite the terribleness of this claim, a key preferred standpoint is that it drives us to rethink the present distributed and estimating model that spots benefit over the interest of the students. Scholastics need to investigate elective open access models keeping in mind the end goal to get through this private benefit syndication shrubbery that has come to torment scholarly distributed.

In this manner, the case by distributors that course packs would crush their business sector for books and put them bankrupt is very faulty. Given this is the first copyright claim to be brought against course packs, one can just expect that the solid development figures gloated by the scholarly distributed industry implies that course packs have not done them much harm.

At last, this claim must be seen for what it is: a profoundly noxious endeavor to fill the coffers of distributors to the detriment of understudies. It must be opposed with all the good and lawful power we have.

The challenge of healthcare infrastructure in India

In the wake of ever increasing diseases like dengue and chikungunya, the importance of ensuring health care access cannot be overstated for a developing country like India. This is on account of separated from the clear thesis that connects health care to the prosperity of citizens; it likewise upgrades the gainful limit of its populace apart from improving economic growth of the nation.

To start with, India’s healthcare infrastructure is to a great extent deficient to serve its immeasurable populace. In the first place, the aggregate number of doctor’s facilities and social insurance experts, public and private included, miss the mark tending to the aggregate interest for health-care facilities, despite being large in numbers. Additionally, the policy makers have been there to address the interest side issues instead of the supply-side wasteful aspects. This is confirmed by the attention on enhancing cleanliness and ecological worries to keep the spread of infirmities and ailments. Albeit a good initiative, these endeavours have neglected to match request with supply.

India represents more than 16 per cent of the world’s population while spending less than 1 per cent of the world’s total health expenditure. Our aggregate health care expenditure remains at 4.1 per cent of GDP, which is among the lowest in the world. The way these assets are dispensed to the States and used adds to the issues. There is generally an impressive postponement of assets dispensed for usage in basic government plans rendering them insufficient. Besides, the assets dispensed for aptitude working of such professionals are not effectively utilised.  

The absence of mindfulness and observing of infections and in addition the means expected to annihilate them represent a genuine test to the social insurance issue. The achievement of polio annihilation in the nation gives us a valid example. This sort of all encompassing methodology is required for handling the expansive number of maladies that still exist in India and are multiplying among its large population. India stays one of only a handful couple of nations where both transferable and non-transmittable maladies are so to a great extent predominant. The changing infection designs represent another genuine test to the social insurance part and finding inventive medications that can cure a substantial number of maladies ought to remain a need.


With chikungunya on a rise, Delhi’s crisis is only getting worse

At last, individuals who matter in Delhi have chosen to give the governmental issues of negativity a break and work together to battle chikungunya and dengue, which have expected plague extents at this point. It took ten chikungunya deaths and endless patients with other vector-borne infections to bode well, and the absence of it in the unending political quarreling when subjects are enduring. It comes somewhat late in the day, yet like they say; it’s preferably late than never.

Come what may; we have to fight the mosquitoes and disease as one. It was cheering to note Union Health Minister JP Nadda extending all backing to the state government. At the point when BJP MP Manoj Tiwari and Pastor Kapil Mishra took a bike ride to Sonia Vihar to join a fumigation drive, it appeared Delhi’s quarreling government officials have developed overnight. Presently, why would this be able to be a changeless element in Delhi? All things considered, the opposition for political space is excessively savage here. That makes sound, agreeable legislative issues is a lot of a desire. In any case, in any event it can be less pessimistic than it is presently. Till several days prior Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal and his Health clergyman Satyendar Jain were rebuking the Lieutenant Governor for the wellbeing mess while the BJP, which controls the MCDs, had been blaming the state government for omissions in get ready for the regular infection flare-up.

There can be no second conclusion that the plan of obligation and responsibility in the city-state stays odd. For state government that detests full powers of a customary state, it calls for monstrous open connection aptitudes and abilities at insightful arrangements to continue onward. With its confrontational, which some would say anarchic, way to deal with existing political conditions the AAP government has demonstrated short on both checks. While its interest for more powers to run the state is not in the least preposterous – in what manner can an administration convey when it has no influence over the police, land and numerous administrations? – the way it has gone about it has abandoned it presented to feedback. The others in the political range have not maintained obligation either.

It appears in the anguish that the poor inhabitants of Delhi are presented to. They need to take the brunt of contamination, sicknesses, lawbreakers, poor city foundation and what not on a normal premise. The spread of the ailments this time mirrors that the guardians of the city are not by any means arranged for what is normal. The normal subject needs to pay the cost for amusements legislators play.

While we can praise the lawmakers for demonstrating some development and meeting up, we should likewise make the inquiry: who is in charge of things resulting in these present circumstances pass? Verging on each family in the city has a chikungunya or dengue persistent. Who’s in charge of that? Serving individuals positively can’t involve political comfort.


Turkey’s careful incursion into Syria: Will it be successful?

The Turkish government recently decided to intervene directly in the clash, sending tanks and an automated infantry brigade across the border into the Ar Rai and Jarablus. It all started went U.S. Vice President Joe Biden went to Ankara for a visit. The Turkish military is battling close by dissidents hailing from different groups, to begin with, to clear Islamic State from the fringe; second, to keep the Syrian Kurds from taking more region west of Manbij; and, third, to hold territory taken. They have succeeded in the first and second goals, is preparing for the third, and now there are talks of a fourth goal: to capture the city of Al Bab from the Islamic State. However, to move towards Al Bab, Turkey would have to build the quantity of ground powers to counterbalance the shortcomings of the Arab and Turkmen local armies battling in the zone.

The Turkish military has taken advantage of favourable terrain to advance quickly along the border, capturing the populated territory ISIL appears to have retreated from. A battle for Al Bab, an urban area with a pre-war populace of 1,30,000 would more difficult. After ISIL has reportedly withdrawn to the city from the border areas, the city’s urban terrain would offer a test for propelling automated infantry and negating the advantages Turkey relied on for operations along the border.

ISIL is currently battling a two and a half-front war in Syria with the northern fringe of its regional territory going under supported ambush from the Kurdish YPG, the most prevailing civilian army in the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF). In this regard, the United States is utilizing the purported light impression model, wherein it inserts uncommon operations strengths with neighborhood components, for this situation the SDF, and influences American airpower to take region. Turkey has loaned backing to this battle, regardless of its profound doubts about the substantial support of the YPG, which is the Syrian branch of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), a guerilla aggregate at present battling Turkish military powers in Turkey’s southeast.

The danger of Turkey getting all the more profoundly included and maybe stalled in Syria might have implications for the United States, the pioneer of the counter Islamic State coalition. In the shorter term, the fundamental risk to Turkish powers is the mass expansion of ATGMs and IEDs in the Syrian clash. In the more extended term, Turkey risks taking region, however not having the capacity to leave on the grounds that the powers battling nearby it can’t be trusted to hold domain. In this situation, the Turkish military may need to stay in Syria until ISIL is crushed or a political arrangement is come to and the battling stops. A key component in Turkey’s choice and the potential for its prosperity on the ground will be the way it manages the IED and ATGM danger to Turkish protective layer and the “following day” objectives of the Turkish mediation power. The destruction of ISIL from the border is something to be thankful for the war, but a bogged down Turkish partner is most certainly not.

Abolishing Governor’s post

After the Union government’s attempt to topple the elected governments of Arunachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand came to the limelight, Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar called for an abolition of the post of governor. The move led to a national outrage, putting the BJP government in a tough spot. The decision of the Supreme Court to reinstate the Arunchal Pradesh government further gave confidence to the opposition that the governor was exercising the powers beyond his constitutional brief.

This is not the first time that the role of the governor has come under the scanner. The fact that Article 365 has been imposed more than 120 times in different states as per the orders of the central government comes as no surprise.  Be it the NDA, Congress or the Janata Party- Third Front, they have misused their status when at the Centre to remove opposition state governments to increase their political powers. The role of governors as constitutional watchdogs has often been camouflaged as they have been found working as agents of the Central government. It has often been noticed that the post of governors as a rule goes to the party loyalists, paying less importance to suitability or merit. Hence, it becomes rather necessary to discuss whether or not there is a need for the abolition of post of Governor in India?

According to the Indian constitution, the primary role of a governor is to act as a link between the Centre and the State w.r.t making the federation strong. With India adopting a diverse multi- religious socio- model, the constitutional makers decided to continue with the post to allow Union government to keep a check on the state governments from pursuing policies that may not be on the same page with national needs. More recently, with the increasing spate of issues arising from naxalism and religious radicalization having been witnessed in the country, the policy makers have stressed on the importance of strong central supervision for which the governor is required. Although the foundation of the institution continues to be sacrosanct, the quality of the incumbents has once again successfully lowered its prestige.

The powers and responsibilities of the governor is set out in Part VI of the Constitution and Article 163 gives them wide discretionary powers, as well as the power to reserve bills under Articles 200 & 201. During times of faulty verdicts, there have been no prescribed norms set for governors on how to formulate government making, and possibility of them getting influenced by central government officials can’t be ignored. He/she has the right to reserve bills sanctioned by the state administrative for the consent of the President or even stall passage of bills that abridge the force of High Court, meddle with the essential structure of the Constitution, influence relations with a remote nation and harm government highlights. The choice of the governor is absolute and can’t be denied in spite of request from the state cabinet once the President has imparted his refusal to the Governor. The governor seeks reports from the state government on the status of bills, sends reports regarding law and order of constitutional machinery, informs the Centre of all the activities in the state and helps maintain an effective central control over states.

Recently, the post of senator has turned into a matter of conflict. The contention is that they are obliged to their political masters and constantly ready to interfere in state legislative issues in order to topple duly chosen governments. However, governors are not the only culprits. The behaviour of the speakers has additionally been a long way from fair and they have not acted according to parliamentary popular government standards. The anti-defection law has been more abused than used rightfully. There has been an overall decline in the values of the democratic system. Getting rid of the governor’s post will be akin to discarding the baby with the bathwater. The Supreme Court decision in the SR Bommai case was notable as in it reduced the force of the Centre to reject state governments discretionarily. In any case, the issue persists. Certain changes should be made to streamline the position of representative, enhance the nature of occupants and give respect to this august office.

The self- assertive dismissals of governors should be stopped at all costs by legislating for a fixed tenure. There should be efforts made for the governor to not work on President’s behalf and his removal from office must entail reprimand procedures in the state assembly. There should be a gap for a governor between acquiring political positions and relinquishing the post to enhance the independence of his office and give him more teeth in functioning. The Punchhi Commission’s recommendation which states that President’s rule should be imposed in those parts of the state where there is law and order breakdown of machinery rather than the whole state can also be given a thought. It might go a long way in preventing the dismissal of state governments on grounds of lawlessness.

Given the development of regional parties, some of which do not have a national viewpoint and stay inserted in parochialism and character governmental issues, presents the defence for holding the organization of governor all the all the more convincing.

The unending struggle

Human rights activist Irom Chanu Sharmila’s decision to end her 16- year-old fast has come as a surprise to most of the people. Her journey has been an intense act of peaceful resistance that successfully undermined the administration’s defence of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act, unearthing its harmful impact on humanity and democracy. Ms. Sharmila began her protest in November 2000 after 10 people were killed, allegedly by the Assam Rifles near Imphal. She sought the revocation of the Act, which gives sweeping powers to security forces in “disturbed places” or states dealing with insurgents. The armed forces were given powers to make arrests without any warrants or raid any area.

Since 1980, the whole of Manipur has been under the Disturbed Areas Act, and in the implied push to battle guerrilla forces, there were regular instances of suspected extrajudicial killings that fed outrage and vulnerability. Irom Sharmila’s forced nourishment through a nasal tube, and solitary confinement in Imphal’s Jawaharlal Nehru Hospital on charges of committing suicide, created a much-needed setting to proceed with dissents in Manipur. In 2004, for instance, around 30 Manipuri women marched naked in Imphal city to protest against the suspected rape and murder of Thangjam Manorama, by a group of Assam Rifles men. In this trajectory of protests against injustice, Ms. Sharmila acquired a place that quickly seemed ageless.  In spite of the government withdrawing AFSPA from segments in Imphal and the Assam Rifles from Kangla, Ms. Sharmila’s constant struggle against the act brought a unique visibility to it. And by ending the fast, she has ironically managed to bring the issue back to the limelight.

For years now, however, another picture has come out. Irom Sharmila has been giving sporadic hints that she wants to lead a normal life. For instance, wanting to marry once the objective of the fast has been achieved, or by looking for her entitlement to vote. Her decision to join politics and stand for Assembly elections seems to arise due to these reasons. It is also a rebuke to the civil society in the rest of the country that failed to provide the support she needed. The cause remains. This month the Supreme Court provided hope that crimes committed under the ambit of AFSPA could be investigated and justice could be won for 1,527 cases in Manipur. However, one thing became crystal clear; fasts like these can only be sustained with a conviction that comes with public support.



The Latur district in Marathwada area of Maharashtra is facing one of the worst droughts in four decades. The circumstance in which the district is reeling under acute water shortage is alarming to say the least. Those, who can bear, have officially left the city looking for greener pastures. The authorities concerned have failed to provide drinking water in the promised quantities. And all over the place, it is the poor man who is suffering the most.

The Maharashtra government seems to believe that it has fulfilled its role by declaring 12,000 villages in the state as drought-affected. While such declaration may help some get the benefits of government subsidies, it will hardly meet the drinking water needs of the people of Latur. The reasons for this dry spell are not unknown to the world. The locals have blamed the presence of factories drawing large amount of ground water for this condition. They have also pointed at the contracted region of woods in the region and wrong agricultural practices leading to depletion of ground water resources. While the city has been booming exponentially, not enough attention has been given to its infrastructural development. Latur is not an isolated case. There are several towns in the Marathwada area itself where the situation is just insignificantly better. The city is a case of everything that isn’t right about urban planning.

Sooner than later, comparative circumstances can emerge in numerous urban areas, even in southern India. Too bad, no consideration is being paid to meet their long haul needs. For example, there can be no two opinions on the need to harvest rainwater. At present, the majority of the downpour water is permitted to stream into waterways and from that point into the ocean. There is a need to gather downpour water in lakes, tanks and repositories to both let the water saturate the earth to increase the groundwater level and to be drawn when the rains are over. Similarly, encroachment is a worrying issue. While handling this issue, the government ought to come up with few water harvesting techniques. Solapur, in spite of being one of the worst drought affected districts in Maharashtra, has successfully met its water needs because of multi-pronged steps like pipeline extension and securing water resources. These measures in principle should be attempted in other districts also.

There is a principle in economics which states that a crisis should not be wasted. It is high time that we take measures to curb this purely man- made situation rather than blaming the weather gods.